I recently helped my mother-in-law pick out paint for her house using my self-developed-super-awesome-paint-picking-method.
All kidding aside, this process really works.
It's fool proof, and you will seriously love your color every time. You will NEVER have to do a re-paint.
I have to be honest, I kind of like painting. I know, I know, there are not many of us out there that do. But I can tell you - there is NO ONE that likes REpainting ;)
Note, this process can be time consuming - I think it took us 3 hours to pick out our color. BUT consider how much longer it would've taken for you to paint over a color you thought would look good, but doesn't. Or how long you'd have to suffer with it if you weren't able to paint over it right away? Seriously - it's worth it.
Seven Steps to the Perfect Paint Color
Step 1: Find Out What You're Working With
Go to the paint store and literally (see below) LITERALLY grab EVERY SINGLE swatch in the color family that you are thinking of painting. Even if you say to yourself "there is NO WAY I will pick that color!" - grab the color card anyway. Just. take. it.
I know. It's hard. I've been through ALL of the inner-monologues.
"I can't do that. I'm NEVER going to pick that color. Why waste the card?!"
"I can't do that. People will think I'm a hoarder!"
"I can't do that. The clerk is going to look at me with disgust because I'm taking so many"
"I can't do that. People are going to look at me like I'm crazy!"
You can do it! I promise! First - that's what they're THERE for. For you to take. And one thing that you most certainly can and possibly will do if you don't follow this method is paint your wall a color that you don't like.
Look at all of our pretty cards!
(This lady is a kook. Who wants that many colors to choose from? Isn't this going to make the process MORE confusing???)
No. I promise. Just hang in there.
Step Two: Start the Picking
Start holding the cards up to your wall one by one, and if you even remotely, slightly, maybe like it, tape it up on the wall.
Here are our "remotely, slightly, maybes" :)
Step Three: Keep Narrowing
Now that you've narrowed it down a bit (it's totally OK if you have WAY more than this in your process) start narrowing even further. Picture those colors spread across your entire wall. Take more than .05 seconds to consider them - you'll start seeing all kinds of things (see below for what I mean by this...)
Here is our slightly narrowed bunch of colors. Of the three beige colors towards the top - can you see how the middle one has a bit of a green hue to it? I guarantee that you would not have seen this green hue in the paint store. Nope. Instead, you would've seen it all over your wall, had you gone in the paint store and said "oh that's a pretty color!" (which I'm sure it is, in some rooms, with specific lighting and decor elements, just maybe not your rooms and lighting and decor).
Keep narrowing until you just can't narrow any further. Sometimes this is down to only 2 or 3 colors. Sometimes - like my experience when I painted my dining room red - it's more (6 to be exact).
These are the two we narrowed it down to.
Step Four: Get Samples and Paint Patches
Most paint stores offer some kind of sampling option. Whether it be $1.50 for a little dropper bottle sized sampler with brush included, or in our case $3.99 for a quart "rental" that we had to return to the store once we had painted on our sample squares. We got our two colors, plus a third color that a friend has in her house that we thought we might like (I DON'T recommend this - because every color looks different in every house. But if you are convinced your friend's living room wall would look amazing in your house, get the color card from the store for that color and mix it in with the rest, and see if you naturally are drawn to it during your narrowing process).
Once you have obtained sample paint, paint it around the room.
Why so many patches? Because this color is going on every wall in the house, and the lighting is very different on each wall.
Step Five: Live With It
Don't be in a huge rush to get to the paint store, unless you painted it on in the daylight, and the sun has now gone down, OR you can simulate "evening" (ie - lights on in the house are the only form of light in the house) pretty well. If you have a lot of windows that don't have very light-blocking blinds or curtains on them, your best bet is to wait it out. You want to view these patches in every form of light - bright daylight and evening incandescent/fluorescent light supplied by the lamps or lighting in your house.
Step Six-A: There's Your Color!
Once you have seen your choices in all forms of light, seen it on your wall next to your stuff or your carpet or your curtains, then you'll know. It'll pop right out at you screaming "I'm right here!" Then, and only then, can you go purchase the paint and start the paint job.
Step Six-B: Still Don't Love Your Color? Go to a Different Paint Store
Sometimes the most convenient paint store isn't the best one. For example, we tried using the closest, local paint store to pick our accent wall color, but they just didn't have what we were looking for. So we went elsewhere, and found the perfect color. Actually, our main color, accent color, and trim color are ALL from different companies. Thankfully, most paint retailers either have the competitor's paint codes (best option) or can color match (next best option) so don't be afraid to grab color cards from where ever you are, even if you plan on buying the paint somewhere else.
(OPTIONAL) Step Seven: Repeat!
If you are needing to pick an accent wall color, or a trim color, do the process over again, but ONLY after you have picked your main color, and use the patch (or the painted wall if you've painted already) as the setting for the other colors.
Here we are picking trim colors - you would be AMAZED at how different each shade of white is.
Notes:
Accent Walls - Picking a color for an accent wall? Make sure you hold your color cards and paint your patches of test paint in the corner. This ensures you will get an accurate feel of the accent color when paired up with your existing wall color.
Fireplaces and Furnishings - Make sure you consider the color against other things in your house that you are not getting rid of or "making over." My mother-in-law has a brick fireplace, so we had to make sure that the color she picked went well against the brick. If you have furniture or window treatments you are not planning on changing out, make sure the color goes well with them. Sometimes this means you will have to narrow down what color you paint. For example, our old place had a very open concept. I had already painted our dining room red, and the rest of the house was this wonderful subtle oatmeal-y neutral. I decided one day that I wanted to paint our living room wall. I was having an oatmeal overload. Sitting on our mustard yellow microfiber couch in our living room, you had our lovely red dining room in your peripheral vision, and saw them both, and the wall I wanted to paint all in one view when you walk in the front door. So when I decided to paint our living room wall, I pretty much had to go with orange. Yellow + Blue + Red = primary colors. Not my ideal color palette for the inside of a house. Yellow + Green + Red = Mexican Fiesta? Lemons and Limes in one eye and Christmas in the other? No thanks. So my only options left were purple and orange. I ended up picking an orange that I totally loved, but when through this whole process with both colors.
Hope this is helpful for all of you at some point! :)